The Official Community of Buddy Holly

Album Reviews

An overview of the reviews for all the albums showcased on this site.

  • Discuss This Page!
Read what the fans are saying about their favorite Buddy Holly CD’s purchased from the Buddy Holly Store!

Want to submit a review of your favorite Buddy Holly CD? Write a Review here.

All Music Guide: Buddy Holly: Singles +Link to another Web site

This collection starts deeper and more interesting than its title would lead one to expect, and for 29 of its 45 songs, it's also wonderfully enjoyable.

All Music Guide: Buddy Holly: Reminiscing/ShowcaseLink to another Web site

Reminiscing is a very solid album, and was essential to the maintaining of Holly's memory. Showcase, is a slightly less consistent record overall, but has some killer rock & roll tracks.

All Music Guide: Buddy Holly: Only the Love SongsLink to another Web site

Buddy singing on standouts like "Raining in My Heart," "True Love Ways," and "Heartbeat," his vintage master recordings augmented with the barber shop-style backing vocals of the Picks.

All Music Guide: Various: Not Fade Away (Remembering Buddy Holly)Link to another Web site

Though it is clear the artists on the tribute are sincere in their affection for Holly, their covers add nothing to the original versions.

All Music Guide: Buddy Holly: Holly in the Hills/GiantLink to another Web site

It's all a lot of fun to hear and enjoyable enough, if not a serious Holly release, and it's never sounded better.

All Music Guide: Buddy Holly: From the Original Master TapesLink to another Web site

This remains the best single-disc collection of Buddy Holly's music, featuring 20 of his biggest hits.

All Music Guide: Buddy Holly: Greatest Hits [Remaster]Link to another Web site

Greatest Hits is one of the most thorough single-disc collections ever assembled on Holly and for audiophiles, it may be worth the extra money.

All Music Guide: Buddy Holly: 20th Century MastersLink to another Web site

Apart from the presumptuous title, 20th Century Masters — The Millennium Collection turns out to be a very good budget-line series.

Hollyville U.K.: That'll Be The DayLink to another Web site

Discouraged but not beaten,within weeks of this final session Buddy was making plans to go to Clovis, New Mexico to see if Norman Petty could bring success!

The Scotsman: Return of the sun kingLink to another Web site

Buddy Holly is a slightly more contentious inclusion, even if he did live fast, die young and leave a geeky-looking corpse.
Nashville's finest celebrating a seminal influence in the best way they know how.

All Music Guide: Review: American PieLink to another Web site

The album has an overall elegiac quality that makes it sound like a final statement. After all, if the music has died, what else is there to say?

All Music Guide: Buddy Holly: The "Chirping" Crickets [Remaster]Link to another Web site

As a piece of self-generated rock & roll, The "Chirping" Crickets was amazingly close to a personalized artistic "statement," in a way that Presley's RCA albums could never be.

All Music Guide: Buddy Holly: The Great Buddy HollyLink to another Web site

This is a fun record, if not really representative of Holly's fully developed style, and ought to interest not only his fans, but also anyone who wants to learn a little more about the early days of the rock & roll boom.

PopMatters: Buddy Holly and The Crickets: The "Chirping" CricketsLink to another Web site

Their songs transcend any and all modern assessments, as they form the very foundation for the phenomenon of rock and roll.

PopMatters: Buddy Holly: ReminiscingLink to another Web site

Reminiscing demonstrates how successful a musician can be. Although the individual tracks are undoubtedly better in their original form, the album itself is probably the starting point of modern rock music.

All Music Guide: Buddy Holly: The Buddy Holly CollectionLink to another Web site

Absolutely necessary for anybody who loves American music of the 20th century.

All Music Guide: Buddy Holly: That'll Be the Day/RememberLink to another Web site

It is the first 11 songs here, from That'll Be the Day, that make this CD an important release, very close to essential.